The Strategic Importance of Payroll
May 27, 2016 | David Barak
There has been a revolution in many areas of business management brought out by the increasing automation of key tasks and the outsourcing of the more menial and labor intensive administrative functions. Across the board, professionals have largely shifted focus from task management to value-based contributions and process improvement.
The shift has coincided with the automation of their functions. For example, the early automation of accounting functions, enhanced access to data, and development of financial modeling software over the 1980s and 1990s led to fundamental changes in the roles of Finance Directors and Chief Financial Officers. More recently, the shift of focus has been especially remarkable in human resources.
Suddenly, HR is dedicating itself to attracting, recruiting, developing, managing, and retaining talent, predicting skills shortages and developing and executing plans to address them. This represents a major shift from HR’s traditional function – the tactical management of personnel considerations –to the development of insight and the creation of value.
Consequently, HR makes a more strategic contribution to the executive management of enterprises, especially multi-national companies. And again, automation is to thank: HCM systems allow HR professionals to lessen the burden of departmental and functional management (and procedural drudgery) and seize their place at the decision makers’ table.
EVOLUTION OF BUSINESS ANALYTICS
As business trends shift and automation expands, new business areas come under scrutiny and are subsequently made accountable for the strategic value they impart, not just the efficiency of the tactical, functional, and administrative exercise of their duties.
Is payroll next on the list?
Payroll remains a tactical function in nearly every company. Indeed, at CloudPay, we still refer to our customers as “early adopters” – a select group with the foresight and vision to recognize that more comprehensive, automation-driven payroll management enables the global payroll function to make strategic as well as tactical contribution.
Tactically, it's essential to pay employees accurately and on-time. Done well, and the function becomes invisible due to professionalism and diligence of payroll managers and staff… and is therefore under-evaluated and under-appreciated. And yet, payroll represents an enormous percentage – often the highest percentage – of the total expenses of an organization.
COMMON PAYROLL CHALLENGES
As such, payroll should be the source of a vast amount of data, chronological and geographic, demographic and functional, from which can be derived a wealth of business information and strategic insight. Payroll trend analysis and predictive analytics should provide entities real competitive advantage, underwriting the best informed decisions.
But to keep pace with myriad and continual changes to the rules, policies, procedures, models, allowances and rates that govern the management of payroll locally, in each separate legislature, companies have maintained payroll staff locally or outsourced the function to local payroll providers – sometimes at a regional level, but more often at the country or legislature level. This spider’s web of suppliers is usually disguised by the entire function being outsourced to an aggregator.
An aggregator is one of the many global payroll providers that manages the supplier network on behalf of its clients, and runs the payroll function, but deliberately gives little or no thought to the strategic opportunity that is being missed. The approach is antiquated, but it’s not going anywhere.
Why so? Because the companies that have grown fat maintaining the status quo are unlikely to want to dismantle their castle by automating the global payroll management process, assimilating complex data sets, and providing the tools for multinationals to centrally manage and analyze their payroll while benefiting from significant efficiencies. It is in no way in the interests of the large aggregators and managed payroll outsourcers to enable or encourage payroll to become strategic.
However, the resistance is futile: Aggregated global payroll solutions are writing themselves out of the future of payroll management by failing to evolve their business models – thus allowing those with greater vision to disrupt the market they have considered their own since the earliest days of data processing.
So what will enable payroll to become strategic? There are two main contributory factors:
- First, automation is needed. Until recently, no company had tackled the complexity of global payroll; the calculation of algorithms that vary from legislature to legislature and the continual state of flux as taxation models are continually adjusted for fiscal advantage by treasury departments of governments worldwide. Even had they done so, until the emergence of the cloud and Software as a Service (SaaS) applications, the sheer administration of the application software given the rate of changes to the underlying algorithms involved proved an insurmountable obstacle, one with which even, maybe especially, the largest suppliers of enterprise software applications refused to grapple.
- Secondly, and perhaps even more importantly, is changing working practice inside the departments that manage payroll in large organizations. The changes required might necessitate a change to the nature of functional management. After all, the skills to understand and manage the process will usually be different from those needed to analyze and extract business intelligence from raw data. Or are they?
In an article by Keith Rodgers in ‘Payroll Professional,’ Maurice Cheng, Chief Executive of the Institute of Payroll Professionals, is cited as arguing that nothing beats the knowledge that comes from working with payroll data every day to give professionals the context and insight they need to fully understand it. He believes, it is said, that payroll professionals are better placed than anyone to provide this kind of information service: “There are a number of senior payrollers [sic] who do this quite effectively – you can’t generalize that all payrollers must be transaction-focused.”
The executive expectation of the contribution that should be made by ‘payroll’ and the influence that global payroll managers have needs to be reviewed and a change of focus to recognize the strategic, not just the tactical, importance of payroll will result.
The former requirement was satisfied by the advent of the cloud and SaaS application pioneered by CloudPay. The latter is, right now, being driven by the need for global payroll data assimilation to big data initiatives and, of course, the professional and corporate successes being enjoyed by the early adopters.
Payroll is often subjugated within HR, just as often within Finance. Yet, payroll as a discipline, as a function and as a strategic contributor of information, belongs to neither; it is a separate entity that is slowly developing its own voice and earning its place on the executive management committees of the world’s most far-sighted multinationals.